Having the ability to customize your island is Animal Crossing Bells extremely trendy, but the real time aspect means my island felt half baked. I'd begin to execute an idea, spend two weeks moving buildings, then realize I don't like the result. I guess I should focus on the advantages of the island reshaping, but that was something that left me feeling bummed.
The crafting system is cool, but the lack of infinite durability tools has basically made me never want to touch the game again. Or why any tools will need to break. Is it just a mild inconvenience to make/buy new tools? Sure. Nonetheless, it adds almost zero benefits to the sport. In Breath of the Wild, your weapons burst. Some found this bothersome, I quite liked it. Why? And I had lots of weapons at once and gathered them passively so changing to a new weapon was not a chore. In New Horizons, switching to a different fishing pole after yours breaks changes nothing about the gameplay. Each rod is the same as the last, there is no importance to any fishing rod. Unless you are actively timing your usage to coincide with excursions to sell your fish then you'll have to waste time working into a store or crafting bench. It is a badly designed system that directly up ruined fishing and bug catching.
Speaking of bug catching, Nintendo chose to ruin that too. Exterior of grabbing beetles on the island at New Leaf, bug catching has always been terrible for making money. It was much easier to capture fish. Several bugs with strong spawn prices were really worth good money. I was enjoying making 300k or so an hour by knowingly catching bugs. Given the prices of the large ticket items at the store, that seemed about fair, and was pretty equal to fishing. Then Nintendo nerfed the spawn rates of the great bugs for apparently no reason. They also cracked down on the attention you got for having bells at the bank. It seemed like Nintendo thought it was too easy to earn money, but they dismissed the largest moneymaker, the Stalk Market. In previous matches, the Stalk Market has been an true gamble. Seeing different cities was a really involved process, in order that you were essentially relying on your prices. With the rise of social networking and the relative simplicity of visiting different islands (a procedure which is still dogshit dreadful, Nintendo never ceases to amaze with their internet ineptitude) it became commonplace to find a good turnip price each week to not merely double, but triple or quadruple your investment. And with the greater stock, buying a high number of turnips was trivial. So people may easily create countless bells with little effort and virtually zero risk.
Do I Believe I'll return into New Leaf? No, not really. The Switch is easier to play with its quicker load times and larger screen. It looks prettier. There are nonetheless a few quite welcome QoL improvements.
You can't blame people for buy Animal Crossing New Horizons Nook Miles Ticket wanting a game to have.... Gameplay.